![]() If the problem goes away then it's either the way Passkey is ripping the disc, or BDinfo isn't being clever enough. If I was you, I'd try ripping a "problem" disc using HD-DVD/Blu-Ray Stream Extractor or Clown BD with Passkey just decrypting in the background. I don't recall ever having to pick which mpls file to rip, unless there's multiple versions of the same movie in different languages, but then it's easy to work out which one is correct. It's been a while since I've ripped a Bluray disc, but I'm sure even when ripping discs which use multiple mpls, if I run AnyDVD in the background and open the disc using HD-DVD/Blu-Ray Stream Extractor, it just opens the appropriate mpls file and displays which m2ts files it's using. Did you decide 00005.MPLS or 00004.M2TS were correct for Hunger Games? I can't vouch for it's accuracy, but I'm sure you could verify a few titles before you decide to trust it. It's a list of Bluray titles with their running times, and if you click on a title it takes you to the post with further details including the mpls/m2ts file to use. Next time I rip one of those discs I'll have to pay more attention.Īnyway, I came across this a little while ago. Maybe the only way to work out which is the correct title is by checking them, although you'd assume if a Bluray player can tell which one is correct then ripping software should be able to. It's possible you're not having problems when using the PS3 as many discs contain PS3 updates which I assume are installed automatically? You're not using an old version of BDInfo are you? It was updated to fix handling of multi-whatsit discs a while back. If you're not re-encoding it probably doesn't make much difference either way (you still have to mux the MKV containing the video with the audio stream after extracting with HD-DVD/Blu-Ray Stream Extractor), but if you're converting it might save time by eliminating the extra ISO step. I use the latter mainly because it's a tool built into MeGUI, which I generally use for encoding. I don't know if ripping to an ISO could be causing the problem, but it there any particular reason you do it that way? I use the same method as fritzi93, only instead of running Passkey in the background and extracting with Clown BD, I run AnyDVD in the background and extract with HD-DVD/Blu-Ray Stream Extractor. Mind you I've only ripped a handful of those multi-whatsit discs using AnyDVD but I didn't seem to have any problems doing so. This practice only serves to irritate those of us who legitimately own the blu-ray discs and desire to be able to access them more conveniently via a hard drive rip instead of loading individual physical discs.Have you tried AnyDVD HD? I'd be curious to see if it makes the same choices as DVDFab. The most severe case I've seen of this has been Downton Abbey Season 5. This puts the scenes out of order in the final rip. The only time you'll know when the studio is deliberately messing with the ripping process is when they have multiple (sometimes dozens of) versions of the same program material but with the segment maps out of order. However, the 1st, 2nd, 4th, and 5th titles are flipped in order in relation to the middle title (1st is 5th, 2nd is 4th). For instance, the Star Trek TNG blu rays have 5 episodes per disc and the third title is always the correct one. Artistic arrangement of the episode selection might require different ordering of the titles. ![]() I think the out of order titles is a result of how they set up episode selection via the on-screen menu system when the disc normally plays in a blu-ray player.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |